I think that instead of rebuilding the Republican party, a new party should emerge from the left. The Republican Party seems to be a party that values paying a lot for national defense, favors very little governmental regulation of financial markets, and coddles bigots (sorry, "values voters"). Once you take away the bigotry and anti-woman posing, there is nothing unique about the Republican Party's arguments, and the new faces of the Republican Party, like Meghan McCain, have advocated toning down the anti-gay and anti-abortion rhetoric. Without that, there's really nothing different between the two parties. Both favor proportionately big defense spending and a combination of free market principles and governmental regulation.
The world has seen the problems with an unregulated financial sector, and we must re-regulate our markets if we want to remain a robust global trading partner. There is no way that Europe and Asia will trade with us and intertwine their markets with ours if we don't fix the lack of regulations that led to undercapitalized banks, toxic assets, and "too big to fail". Free market capitalism isn't a real argument anymore; there is just a discussion about how much regulation the market can tolerate, and Obama has espoused his confidence in the free market and his desire to let it work as much as possible. This is also true on the health care side: Obama does not advocate for a single-payer system to replace our current non-system. Instead, he offers a plan that creates a government system that will compete with the insurance industry's plans for American's dollars. Obama has increased defense spending and seems to be expanding our military's presence in AfPak, which will finance the work of defense contractors for years.
On the social issues: they're dying. Young people are less religious and also less likely to oppose gay marriage than any previous generation. Birth control is commonplace (though not commonplace enough). Almost nobody abstains from sex until marriage, and cohabitation rates are up. The Right has lost the culture war it waged. Meanwhile, Obama hasn't yet repealed Don't Ask Don't Tell, Barkey Frank stripped EDNA of any reference to employment discrimination protection for transgendered persons, and nobody has suggested the Full Faith and Credit problems with the Federal Defense of Marriage Act. Essentially, DOMA says that no state needs to recognize a gay marriage that occurred in any other state. However, the Full Faith and Credit Clause of the Constitution says that states have to respect the "public acts, records, and judicial rulings" of other states. DOMA is patently unconstitutional. Obama is not a radical. He doesn't even favor same sex marriage. His stance is slow-moving and moderate on social issues, no matter what the abstinence-funding, purity-ball-attending, gay-bashing crowd thinks.
Obama's presidency is moderate, with respect to social issues as well as policy. Clinton's was, too. A Progressive/Socialist party that advocates governmental interaction with the market on a much larger scale would provide a meaningful alternative to this Democratic party, one that respects market freedom as well as regulation. The real questions that remain are on the Left: debates over legalization of marijuana and perhaps other drugs, birth control pills available over-the-counter, vastly expanded infrastructure spending, low defense spending and a non-agressive foreign policy, federal regulation of the market on a scale heretofore reserved for the dreaded France (be afraid!), the expansion of the welfare state in an attempt to level out the class system and eradicate poverty, socialized medicine, gay marriage at the federal level, and a provision prohibiting discrimination based on LGB and also T status in employment and housing.
We need voices to the left of the Democratic Party's current incarnation to help implement a truly progressive agenda and to give people who oppose GOP bigotry and big guns a real choice about how far left they wish to go. This country desparately needs to give voters more choices than two! We are multicultural, multilingual, and multiracial. We have different sexual orientations and different concepts of family. We are Americans, and our political discourse must expand.
Tuesday, May 12, 2009
Sunday, May 3, 2009
Death Penalty: Delara Darabi
Delara Darabi, a 23-year-old Iranian woman, was executed Friday. She had confessed to a murder when she was 17, but later recanted. She said that her boyfriend, who was 19 at the time, had convinced her to confess. They thought that she wouldn't be executed, since she was a minor. He is currently serving 10 years for his part in the murder. She was executed alone; neither her family nor her lawyer were informed, although notifying them is her right per Iraqi law.
Is executing juvenile offenders ever right? This is a separate question to whether the death penalty is ever right, I think; does the government have a greater obligation to give juvenlies a second chance than it does to extend the same to adults? If the government structures its laws around the idea that minors and children cannot be held to the same expectations of impulse control and decisonmaking skills that society expects of adults, then yes. A government that does not recognize a minor as a full adult cannot justly punish a minor when she fails to act with the good judgment required of a full adult.
Some critics might contend that 17 and 18 years of age are not meaningfully different in terms of developmental ability. That might be true, and surely it varies among people. However, once the government has decided that 18 years of age is a meaningful proxy for good decisionmaking and sufficient life experience, the government is bound by that proxy. 17 is different than 18, even when it's not, because the government says so. Therefore the government can't justly expect a certain level of responsibility from 17 year olds in all but one context, when that single outlier context is the one in which the government intrudes upon the very life of that person. It is impermissible for the government's inconsistency to result in the ultimate imposition of the state upon the citizen.
This line of analysis might also be meaningful in a women's right context, especially in a legal system that singles women out as dependents of men. In Iran several laws require that men act as providers and represetatives for women: women can't get a passport without their husbands' permission, they are barred from certain professions, and a woman's life is considered to be worth half of a man's life. These laws suggest that a woman cannot take care of herself. She is inferior in every way to a man, lacking self-control and the ability to function in the world. Any legitimate government, in refusing to confer upon a segment of society the rights and responsibilities of its fully-functioning members, must similarly refuse to punish that segment for failing to exhibit those rights and responsibilities. In other words, in a legitimate society, the government can't have it both ways: either I'm an adult with full rights and control over my actions, and therefore culpable for my sins, or I'm not, and I'm not.
Iran executes more juveniles than any other country, even though it has joined the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child, which prohibits executing people whose crime was committed before their eighteenth birthday.
So let's turn to a free society, for comparison. In the US, we executed juvelines in 19 states until 2005. We executed those with mental impairments until 2002.
Is executing juvenile offenders ever right? This is a separate question to whether the death penalty is ever right, I think; does the government have a greater obligation to give juvenlies a second chance than it does to extend the same to adults? If the government structures its laws around the idea that minors and children cannot be held to the same expectations of impulse control and decisonmaking skills that society expects of adults, then yes. A government that does not recognize a minor as a full adult cannot justly punish a minor when she fails to act with the good judgment required of a full adult.
Some critics might contend that 17 and 18 years of age are not meaningfully different in terms of developmental ability. That might be true, and surely it varies among people. However, once the government has decided that 18 years of age is a meaningful proxy for good decisionmaking and sufficient life experience, the government is bound by that proxy. 17 is different than 18, even when it's not, because the government says so. Therefore the government can't justly expect a certain level of responsibility from 17 year olds in all but one context, when that single outlier context is the one in which the government intrudes upon the very life of that person. It is impermissible for the government's inconsistency to result in the ultimate imposition of the state upon the citizen.
This line of analysis might also be meaningful in a women's right context, especially in a legal system that singles women out as dependents of men. In Iran several laws require that men act as providers and represetatives for women: women can't get a passport without their husbands' permission,
Iran executes more juveniles than any other country, even though it has joined the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child, which prohibits executing people whose crime was committed before their eighteenth birthday.
So let's turn to a free society, for comparison. In the US, we executed juvelines in 19 states until 2005. We executed those with mental impairments until 2002.
Friday, April 17, 2009
Afghanistan Update
Karzai is going to reverse the law legalizing marital rape and rolling back the rights of Afghan women.
Good job, internal and external outrage!
Good job, internal and external outrage!
Isolating out the misogyny.
Ok this post is a little different: it's not about the Muslim world. It is inspired by McCain's former campaign manager's comments about gay marriage. It made me think about the unifying ability of culture war issues like gay marriage and abortion, and what unifies the GOP without those issues. I don't think, tea parties notwithstanding, that a philosophy of low taxes and little government intrusion is actually the foundation of the GOP. In reality, many doctrinaire Regan-type Republicans are ok with taxes that enable defense spending, and many religious Republicans are ok with government intrusion, as long as it focuses on private intimate conduct and not on regulation of capital markets. I want to explore, in this post, how some coalitions built on culture war issues are made up of groups that should not agree, even when taking into account ugly and irrational positions. The anti-birth control AND anti-abortion stance is one such coalition. People who believe that birth control availability and a right to abortion ought not to be legal must take that stance because they want to punish women who have sex or else because their religion mandates that stance. Neither of these reasons is an acceptable rationale upon which to make national policy.
The forced-birth crowd, aka anti-abortion, anti-sex education AND anti-birth control people, care only about control of women and not about anything else. Disclaimer: I am making these arguments from a disgusting starting point; I do not accept their premises (for example I don't believe that non-white people are inferior to white people).
White racists and people who hate or resent the poor should be pro government-funded birth control and pro abortion. Poor people are disproportionally non-white. Poor people have the most to gain from government funded programs. So, the government would be funding the birth control that helps to prevent people of color from reproducing. Safe, legal abortion would be available as a backup in case pregnancy is unintended and/or the product of sexual assault (and sexual assault is disproportionately common in communities of color.)
Providing birth control is better than just telling poor people and people of color not to have sex since 1) obviously that doesn't work and 2) it's easier just to give people birth control and not have to try to enforce abstinence. Abstinence education costs a lot of money, though I don't know how much in relation to providing birth control costs. However, I'd be surprised if the decrease in unwanted pregnancies didn't save the government money on emergency room trips for uninsured mothers and early-childhood education and health care.
The third reason to give birth control rather than to just tell people of color and poor people not to have sex requires a bit of intellectual honesty on the part of racists, which I know is a tall order. Bear with me: if you are a racist, you think brown people aren't as good as you, a white person. You think they're not as smart, don't make good decisions, lack discipline or fortitude, and aren't as worthy of human rights. This line of thought presupposes that human rights can be deserved, instead of inherent, but that's another post. Anyway, if you really believe people of color don't make good decisions or lack discipline, then why would you expect them to think: "I can't afford a baby, I better suppress my biological urges all the time so I don't get pregnant". That would take good decision-making skills and discipline! If you're a racist, you can't really hope that non-white people acquire discipline or decision-making skills or those good things you think they lack. If they did, that would totally disrupt your white supremacist hierarchy, leaving you without the white privilege that you depend on for your self-esteem. So, if they lack decision-making skills and discipline and those cannot be acquired, you could just make birth control available and then those problems go away.
Those who think that American-style capitalism is the only acceptable model should be on board with America promoting widespread birth control and abortion rights overseas. During the communist era, the US policy abroad was to encourage population control with the use of contraception, in order to maintain capitalism's hegemony by crippling the growth of communist countries. Michelle Goldberg's book, The Means of Reproduction, examines this history. People who work from a colonialist model and wish to guarantee American economic hegemony rather than a cooperative global economy should like the idea of encouraging small family size and widespread use of birth control in the developing world.
People who believe single mothers are irresponsible and bad parents should be in favor of birth control and abortion. The 80's version of single-mother hate came from Reagan's phrase "welfare queen". When people describe single mothers, the stigmatizing effect of the phrase "welfare queen" is still evident. It is present in allegations that single mothers raise kids on food stamps and welfare, and single mothers' kids go to prison. If women had unfettered access to their reproductive rights, we could address this problem, if it is a problem, and if it can be addressed. We would be able to isolate the cases, which I contend would be rare, where women choose to have babies they cannot afford. Why not just tell women not to have sex instead? Because 1) it hasn't worked yet and 2) if you believe single mothers are irresponsible, undisciplined people, then you shouldn't be comfortable banking on their ability to abstain.
And, finally, people who hate abortion should support widespread birth control availability, since it will decrease the abortion rate. I promise, when faced with a low-cost ex-ante method of avoiding unintended pregnancy, women will use that option. Mistakes will be made, but that doesn't mean women aren't rational actors.
Without misogyny, racists, poor-haters, and single-mom haters would be on board with widespread subsidized or free birth control and abortion. I recognize there's a small wrinkle with the people who believe abortion is murder, but we're talking about the disingenuous wingnuts who want to outlaw birth control AND abortion, making family planning and reproductive control a thing of the past. For these people, the problem with birth control is that it takes away reasons not to have sex, and they reject any model in which a woman's sexuality is under her own control. They would rather tell people not to have sex than make it possible for people to engage in sex without the threat of pregnancy. They think sex has consequences. Only bad things have consequences! Good things have "benefits" and morally neutral things have "results". Sex is good. It is an inevitable part of the human experience. It is fun, and free, and it feels good. Why should I refuse to engage in a perfectly healthy, legal, normal activity that I want to do just because a person I have never met says I should?
Sounds like I am saying they hate sex, not that they hate women. Let me be clear: they do hate sex. However, look who absorbs the costs of sex in a world where birth control is not completely avilable: the woman. Look who should have been more careful or worn something different or sent different signals when a rape occurs: the woman. Look who has to "take responsibility" for having sex by carrying a life she didn't intend to create: the woman. If anti-birth control and anti-abortion people hate sex and their perfect model gives women all the resposibility for the costs of sex, that's misogyny. And, without misogyny, the pro-choice movement would have strange allies in the racist, poor-hater communities. I argue that's a good thing because I believe, when it come to keeping women alive and in control of their own bodies, the ends justify the means.
The abortion issue-as-litmus-test is just one situation in which I see the facade of a unified GOP cracking. People inside and outside the party need to regard so-called Republican core issues with a critical eye: to which faction within the GOP is this issue important? Why? How does it relate to the national platform? For example, the more libertarian wing of the party cannot possibly believe that taxes are an affront but interfering in female citizens' bodily integrity is not.
The forced-birth crowd, aka anti-abortion, anti-sex education AND anti-birth control people, care only about control of women and not about anything else. Disclaimer: I am making these arguments from a disgusting starting point; I do not accept their premises (for example I don't believe that non-white people are inferior to white people).
White racists and people who hate or resent the poor should be pro government-funded birth control and pro abortion. Poor people are disproportionally non-white. Poor people have the most to gain from government funded programs. So, the government would be funding the birth control that helps to prevent people of color from reproducing. Safe, legal abortion would be available as a backup in case pregnancy is unintended and/or the product of sexual assault (and sexual assault is disproportionately common in communities of color.)
Providing birth control is better than just telling poor people and people of color not to have sex since 1) obviously that doesn't work and 2) it's easier just to give people birth control and not have to try to enforce abstinence. Abstinence education costs a lot of money, though I don't know how much in relation to providing birth control costs. However, I'd be surprised if the decrease in unwanted pregnancies didn't save the government money on emergency room trips for uninsured mothers and early-childhood education and health care.
The third reason to give birth control rather than to just tell people of color and poor people not to have sex requires a bit of intellectual honesty on the part of racists, which I know is a tall order. Bear with me: if you are a racist, you think brown people aren't as good as you, a white person. You think they're not as smart, don't make good decisions, lack discipline or fortitude, and aren't as worthy of human rights. This line of thought presupposes that human rights can be deserved, instead of inherent, but that's another post. Anyway, if you really believe people of color don't make good decisions or lack discipline, then why would you expect them to think: "I can't afford a baby, I better suppress my biological urges all the time so I don't get pregnant". That would take good decision-making skills and discipline! If you're a racist, you can't really hope that non-white people acquire discipline or decision-making skills or those good things you think they lack. If they did, that would totally disrupt your white supremacist hierarchy, leaving you without the white privilege that you depend on for your self-esteem. So, if they lack decision-making skills and discipline and those cannot be acquired, you could just make birth control available and then those problems go away.
Those who think that American-style capitalism is the only acceptable model should be on board with America promoting widespread birth control and abortion rights overseas. During the communist era, the US policy abroad was to encourage population control with the use of contraception, in order to maintain capitalism's hegemony by crippling the growth of communist countries. Michelle Goldberg's book, The Means of Reproduction, examines this history. People who work from a colonialist model and wish to guarantee American economic hegemony rather than a cooperative global economy should like the idea of encouraging small family size and widespread use of birth control in the developing world.
People who believe single mothers are irresponsible and bad parents should be in favor of birth control and abortion. The 80's version of single-mother hate came from Reagan's phrase "welfare queen". When people describe single mothers, the stigmatizing effect of the phrase "welfare queen" is still evident. It is present in allegations that single mothers raise kids on food stamps and welfare, and single mothers' kids go to prison. If women had unfettered access to their reproductive rights, we could address this problem, if it is a problem, and if it can be addressed. We would be able to isolate the cases, which I contend would be rare, where women choose to have babies they cannot afford. Why not just tell women not to have sex instead? Because 1) it hasn't worked yet and 2) if you believe single mothers are irresponsible, undisciplined people, then you shouldn't be comfortable banking on their ability to abstain.
And, finally, people who hate abortion should support widespread birth control availability, since it will decrease the abortion rate. I promise, when faced with a low-cost ex-ante method of avoiding unintended pregnancy, women will use that option. Mistakes will be made, but that doesn't mean women aren't rational actors.
Without misogyny, racists, poor-haters, and single-mom haters would be on board with widespread subsidized or free birth control and abortion. I recognize there's a small wrinkle with the people who believe abortion is murder, but we're talking about the disingenuous wingnuts who want to outlaw birth control AND abortion, making family planning and reproductive control a thing of the past. For these people, the problem with birth control is that it takes away reasons not to have sex, and they reject any model in which a woman's sexuality is under her own control. They would rather tell people not to have sex than make it possible for people to engage in sex without the threat of pregnancy. They think sex has consequences. Only bad things have consequences! Good things have "benefits" and morally neutral things have "results". Sex is good. It is an inevitable part of the human experience. It is fun, and free, and it feels good. Why should I refuse to engage in a perfectly healthy, legal, normal activity that I want to do just because a person I have never met says I should?
Sounds like I am saying they hate sex, not that they hate women. Let me be clear: they do hate sex. However, look who absorbs the costs of sex in a world where birth control is not completely avilable: the woman. Look who should have been more careful or worn something different or sent different signals when a rape occurs: the woman. Look who has to "take responsibility" for having sex by carrying a life she didn't intend to create: the woman. If anti-birth control and anti-abortion people hate sex and their perfect model gives women all the resposibility for the costs of sex, that's misogyny. And, without misogyny, the pro-choice movement would have strange allies in the racist, poor-hater communities. I argue that's a good thing because I believe, when it come to keeping women alive and in control of their own bodies, the ends justify the means.
The abortion issue-as-litmus-test is just one situation in which I see the facade of a unified GOP cracking. People inside and outside the party need to regard so-called Republican core issues with a critical eye: to which faction within the GOP is this issue important? Why? How does it relate to the national platform? For example, the more libertarian wing of the party cannot possibly believe that taxes are an affront but interfering in female citizens' bodily integrity is not.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
