In Iran, Ahmadinejad is apparently set to nominate three women to the Iranian cabinet. The AP reports that these nominations appear "to be an attempt by Ahmadinejad to win the support of Iranian women as he fends off opposition claims that his re-election to the presidency in June was fraudulent." These would be the first female ministers Iran has had since the 1970's.
Iran, then, provides an example of a leader making concessions to vocal groups in order to safeguard his power. Women were a vocal and visible part of the uprising in Iran, and so Ahmadinejad is throwing them a bone by including women in his cabinet.
I contrast this with Afghanistan, where, as discussed in the previous post, Karzai is capitulating to fundamentalist voices by quietly passing a law that allows husbands to withhold food from wives who refuse to have sex with them, among other things. Rather than kill a law that would legalize marital rape, which caused international outcry in March, Karzai mollified outsiders and then passed the current law, which undermines women's rights to a similar degree.
The question I have is: why? Why does the regime in Afghanistan, which Americans put in place and have supported for 8 years, still need to placate warlords by stripping women of their rights? Why can Iran, one of the most repressive regimes in the world, tolerate more legal protection for women than Afghanistan? Why did the US even throw the Taliban regime out of Afghanistan if the US-supported regime would be similarly offensive to international standards of human rights?
Showing posts with label Iran. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Iran. Show all posts
Monday, August 17, 2009
Monday, June 22, 2009
Thoughts on Iran
I've been watching eagerly as the events unfold in Iran between long bouts of studying for the bar. Here are some quick hits of my reactions:
- Those who want Obama to come out strongly in favor of those who want democracy in Iran confuse me. Iranians are doing this for themselves. Institutional support from the American president is problematic for two reasons. First, overt support from the American government will make the revolution, which belongs to the Iranians, seem less valid in the Muslim world. It could begin to seem like the product of Western influence rather than the product of the Iranian public's outrage over their election. Now, I agree that on a personal level, people from all over the world should support Iranian revolutionaries if they feel called to do so. This method of support is different because it is bottom-up. Grassroots support can bolster a grassroots uprising, where an official Obama-led statement of support for grassroots uprising in Iran could turn it into a fight about imperialism between the US and Iran. Second reason I think the US government should stay out of it is because Iran is not our business. We need to break out of the idea that everyone in the world is waiting to hear what the US thinks of them. They aren't. Look how the revolution has progressed without a statement from Obama. Somehow, people are moved to fight for a legitimate government without the US suggesting it. The only true democracy, the kind that is precious and self-sustaining, is the kind that people want so badly that they will make it happen by any means necessary. Institutional support from the US is misused when it puts the stamp of approval on a movement that has not one thing to do with us.
- Women. Iranian women that are being photographed in the streets, holding up signs, are rocking my world right now. These university-age women, with scarves drooping precipitously from their heads, looking angrily into the crowds, clutching signs with long, painted fingernails, are the face of rebellion. You realize nail polish is illegal in Iran, right? And now the woman they call Neda is a symbol of the protest. This is really amazing in a country that has tried so hard to repress everyone, including women.
Sunday, May 3, 2009
Death Penalty: Delara Darabi
Delara Darabi, a 23-year-old Iranian woman, was executed Friday. She had confessed to a murder when she was 17, but later recanted. She said that her boyfriend, who was 19 at the time, had convinced her to confess. They thought that she wouldn't be executed, since she was a minor. He is currently serving 10 years for his part in the murder. She was executed alone; neither her family nor her lawyer were informed, although notifying them is her right per Iraqi law.
Is executing juvenile offenders ever right? This is a separate question to whether the death penalty is ever right, I think; does the government have a greater obligation to give juvenlies a second chance than it does to extend the same to adults? If the government structures its laws around the idea that minors and children cannot be held to the same expectations of impulse control and decisonmaking skills that society expects of adults, then yes. A government that does not recognize a minor as a full adult cannot justly punish a minor when she fails to act with the good judgment required of a full adult.
Some critics might contend that 17 and 18 years of age are not meaningfully different in terms of developmental ability. That might be true, and surely it varies among people. However, once the government has decided that 18 years of age is a meaningful proxy for good decisionmaking and sufficient life experience, the government is bound by that proxy. 17 is different than 18, even when it's not, because the government says so. Therefore the government can't justly expect a certain level of responsibility from 17 year olds in all but one context, when that single outlier context is the one in which the government intrudes upon the very life of that person. It is impermissible for the government's inconsistency to result in the ultimate imposition of the state upon the citizen.
This line of analysis might also be meaningful in a women's right context, especially in a legal system that singles women out as dependents of men. In Iran several laws require that men act as providers and represetatives for women: women can't get a passport without their husbands' permission, they are barred from certain professions, and a woman's life is considered to be worth half of a man's life. These laws suggest that a woman cannot take care of herself. She is inferior in every way to a man, lacking self-control and the ability to function in the world. Any legitimate government, in refusing to confer upon a segment of society the rights and responsibilities of its fully-functioning members, must similarly refuse to punish that segment for failing to exhibit those rights and responsibilities. In other words, in a legitimate society, the government can't have it both ways: either I'm an adult with full rights and control over my actions, and therefore culpable for my sins, or I'm not, and I'm not.
Iran executes more juveniles than any other country, even though it has joined the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child, which prohibits executing people whose crime was committed before their eighteenth birthday.
So let's turn to a free society, for comparison. In the US, we executed juvelines in 19 states until 2005. We executed those with mental impairments until 2002.
Is executing juvenile offenders ever right? This is a separate question to whether the death penalty is ever right, I think; does the government have a greater obligation to give juvenlies a second chance than it does to extend the same to adults? If the government structures its laws around the idea that minors and children cannot be held to the same expectations of impulse control and decisonmaking skills that society expects of adults, then yes. A government that does not recognize a minor as a full adult cannot justly punish a minor when she fails to act with the good judgment required of a full adult.
Some critics might contend that 17 and 18 years of age are not meaningfully different in terms of developmental ability. That might be true, and surely it varies among people. However, once the government has decided that 18 years of age is a meaningful proxy for good decisionmaking and sufficient life experience, the government is bound by that proxy. 17 is different than 18, even when it's not, because the government says so. Therefore the government can't justly expect a certain level of responsibility from 17 year olds in all but one context, when that single outlier context is the one in which the government intrudes upon the very life of that person. It is impermissible for the government's inconsistency to result in the ultimate imposition of the state upon the citizen.
This line of analysis might also be meaningful in a women's right context, especially in a legal system that singles women out as dependents of men. In Iran several laws require that men act as providers and represetatives for women: women can't get a passport without their husbands' permission,
Iran executes more juveniles than any other country, even though it has joined the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child, which prohibits executing people whose crime was committed before their eighteenth birthday.
So let's turn to a free society, for comparison. In the US, we executed juvelines in 19 states until 2005. We executed those with mental impairments until 2002.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
