Showing posts with label Feminism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Feminism. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 26, 2012

Contraception Access in Public Schools

I was listening to one of my favorite podcasts, This Week In Blackness Radio, recently, and they were discussing a pilot program in 13 NYC public schools, in which school nurses and health professionals have begun dispensing hormonal birth control, including Plan B, to students. Long-term hormonal birth control normally needs a prescription, and nurse-practitioners and other health professionals are often the ones who prescribe it in clinics and doctor's offices. Plan B is available without a prescription to people 17 and older, and it was approved for young women of any age. However, the Department of Health and Human Services opted not to implement that approval and make Plan B available over the counter for people of any age, after a public outcry which featured, as always, a bunch of men hand-wringing over how soon young women in this country should be allowed to have sex.

I was surprised to hear that the concerns voiced by the hosts and most callers-in to the podcast focused on the rights of these high school students' parents. Questions ranged from how parents should be notified, whether the school should have allowed parents to opt-in rather than opt-out, and whether making contraception available in school undermined parents' ability to speak to their children about sex and about potentially harmful medication. This framing for the story is wrong. Instead, the story should center around whether school dispensing birth control to students who want it allows young women to access their own fundamental rights to privacy and bodily autonomy. With the Supreme Court's development of the fundamental right to privacy in personal intimate relationships, American society has diminished the public's right to legislate the sexual behavior of women and replaced it with increasing individual women's rights to decide for themselves the sexual trajectory of their lives. This change has been beneficial to public health by delaying motherhood, spacing births, and allowing women to have lives in which sexual intimacy and pleasure can play a beneficial role, since risks formerly associated with that pleasure are diminished. Allowing young women to access contraception in schools, especially ones in areas where such access is difficult or impossible, safeguards these students’ constitutionally-guaranteed rights over their bodies and their relationships. The rights of their parents to tell them what to do are essentially unimportant in comparison.

The young women who seek to access birth control at school do so while being protected by the constitutional right to privacy over their sexual decisions and relationships. The Supreme Court's jurisprudence has developed in this area over the decades since the 1960's. The Court has interpreted the due process clause of the 14th Amendment to guarantee rights that the Constitution does not list overtly, which the Court terms "substantive due process" rights. The Due Process Clause of the 14th Amendment states that no state shall deprive a citizen of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. The doctrine of substantive due process basically defines the kinds of things that fall into the definition of “life, liberty, or property”, the things that the government cannot take from you without a good reason. These rights include the right to travel freely among the states, the right to refuse medical treatment, the right to choose to have children as one sees fit, the right to raise your kids as you see fit, and the right to have the sexual relationships you want to have without interference from the government.

 The fundamental right to privacy over sexual relationships was first recognized in Griswold v. Connecticut, 381 U.S. 479 (1965) in a case that guaranteed married people the right to use birth control (which had been illegal in some states until that point). The Supreme Court further articulated the right to privacy, and in particular privacy regarding sexual relationships, in Eisenstadt v. Baird, 405 U.S. 438 (1972), which guaranteed the right to use birth control for people who were not married. This implicitly allowed unmarried people the right to have sex for non-procreative reasons. These two cases are the foundation for the privacy right that guarantees women's right to first-trimester abortion as articulated by Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973). Finally, in Lawrence v. Texas, 539 U.S. 558 (2003), the Court struck down sodomy laws in Texas and several other states, holding that intimate sexual acts between adults, even adults of the same sex, are protected by the substantive due process guaranteed by the 14th Amendment. The  substantive due process  right guarantees to the individual the decisions that used to be dictated by “public morality”, usually dominated by Christian Protestant religious morality. Substantive due process takes the personal decisions of women and gays out of the public sphere: women can have sex and not get pregnant if they want. Gays can have sex without fear of criminal consequences. Substantive due process, for many, guarantees liberty regardless of the fact that their lives or choices are different from the dominant view of Christian morality.

Teenagers in this country have their own substantive due process rights, and parents have the right to custody of their own children, and the right to raise them as they see fit. These rights are inherently in tension: how could both a child and a parent have rights over the child's life, and decisions that child makes? First, the fundamental right guaranteed to parents is a right as against the government to raise their child as they see fit, not as against the child. Secondly, some balancing of rights between child and parent is natural in the growing-up process. It simply cannot be that people have no constitutional rights whatsoever until they reach age 18, at which point their parents' total dominion over them ends and their rights are conferred upon them by the government. Instead, as a child reaches sexual and social maturity, that "child's" right to a life of her own necessarily increases, while her parent's rights to determine her fate decrease. The entire point of fundamental rights is that they are fundamental: they guarantee activity that is essential to the human experience. They guarantee rights that allow people to live their lives as they see fit. Teenagers are not exempt from those experiences or goals, or those rights.

 Schools that provide contraception to young women without involving parents (except to let them opt-out of the program) are respecting young women's rights to control their fertility, their ability to access their educational and career goals, and their own health care. Focusing the discussion over this pilot program on the parents' rights to their children's fertility or medical decisions is tantamount to arguing that 17 or 18 year old women in high school don't know what's good for their own lives and bodies.  The only way this argument makes sense is if a 16 or 17 year old girl is too stupid to know what being pregnant means, or to weigh the costs and benefits to having sex, or to take medication with potential side effects. Obviously an attempt to access birth control by a 16 or 17 year old discredits this assumption: a young woman in that position has weighed the costs and benefits to hormonal birth control and to having sex, and to pregnancy, and decided that she wants to have sex but not get pregnant regardless of any side effects of the Pill. Since 1972, this country has recognized her Constitutional right to do just that.  Young women are fundamentally entitled to the responsibility over their own bodies and lives that access to birth control gives them. They are also fundamentally entitled to privacy, which means they get to decide for themselves what people in their lives get to know their decisions. We should trust women with their own health as well as with their knowledge of their own family dynamics: the decision to talk about birth control is as much a young woman’s right as the decision to take it.

Monday, June 22, 2009

Thoughts on Iran

I've been watching eagerly as the events unfold in Iran between long bouts of studying for the bar. Here are some quick hits of my reactions:
  • Those who want Obama to come out strongly in favor of those who want democracy in Iran confuse me. Iranians are doing this for themselves. Institutional support from the American president is problematic for two reasons. First, overt support from the American government will make the revolution, which belongs to the Iranians, seem less valid in the Muslim world. It could begin to seem like the product of Western influence rather than the product of the Iranian public's outrage over their election. Now, I agree that on a personal level, people from all over the world should support Iranian revolutionaries if they feel called to do so. This method of support is different because it is bottom-up. Grassroots support can bolster a grassroots uprising, where an official Obama-led statement of support for grassroots uprising in Iran could turn it into a fight about imperialism between the US and Iran. Second reason I think the US government should stay out of it is because Iran is not our business. We need to break out of the idea that everyone in the world is waiting to hear what the US thinks of them. They aren't. Look how the revolution has progressed without a statement from Obama. Somehow, people are moved to fight for a legitimate government without the US suggesting it. The only true democracy, the kind that is precious and self-sustaining, is the kind that people want so badly that they will make it happen by any means necessary. Institutional support from the US is misused when it puts the stamp of approval on a movement that has not one thing to do with us.
  • Women. Iranian women that are being photographed in the streets, holding up signs, are rocking my world right now. These university-age women, with scarves drooping precipitously from their heads, looking angrily into the crowds, clutching signs with long, painted fingernails, are the face of rebellion. You realize nail polish is illegal in Iran, right? And now the woman they call Neda is a symbol of the protest. This is really amazing in a country that has tried so hard to repress everyone, including women.

Friday, April 17, 2009

Afghanistan Update

Karzai is going to reverse the law legalizing marital rape and rolling back the rights of Afghan women.

Good job, internal and external outrage!

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Entitlement and Marital Rape

Sarah Palin's pick for Attorney General of Alaska is running into some problems. A letter by Leah Burton, reproduced here and here, says that Wayne Anthony Ross spoke at a 1991 meeting of the group Dads Against Discrimination. Burton's letter alleges that Ross said, "If a guy can't rape his wife, who's he gonna rape?" I have several things to say about this statement in isolation, not as an indicator of Ross' potential job performance as AG. It hasn't been proven that he said this yet.
  1. This statement might mean, "If a man can't rape his wife, he will inevitably go rape someone else, and that's not good." I would take issue with the idea that a man is inevitably a rapist. Even if this statement doesn't mean that all men are rapists, it might mean that those men who are rapists should confine their activities to one victim. I disagree that it's helpful to the world to assign one woman to absorb the pain of all potential victims. If a wife is made into the mechanism by which society controls rapists, then society completely ignores any punishment or accountability for rapists themselves. How about wives don't have to be victims of sexual assault at all, because men realize that women's bodies should be under individual women's control?
  2. The more conventional way to read this statement is "If a man can't rape his wife, then what is a wife for?" This view is akin to the idea that marital rape doesn't exist, because "rape" means "have sex with someone without their permission" and wives, through their marriage vows, give their husbands blanket sexual consent until the marriage ends or one spouse dies. This view depends on the idea that women are not people with full agency within marriage, and that their bodily integrity is secondary to their husbands' sexual desires.
The statement attributed to Ross led me to revisit Afghan leader Mohammad Asif Mohseni's statements about the law that grants a husband sexual access to his wife every fourth night. The Globe and Mail reported this story and Mr. Mohseni's statements:
“If she is not sick, and if she does not have another problem, it is the right of a man to ask for sex and she should make herself ready for it. This is the right of a man,” Mr. Mohseni explained.

Mr. Mohseni argued that women and men are very far from equal in today's Afghanistan and should not be treated as such. He pointed out that many rural women are illiterate and would not be able to find work if they were asked to provide some of the family's financial support. Men are typically the breadwinners in Afghan households, expected to provide for their wives and children.

“It is not possible for all women to pay the same amount of money as men are paying. For all these expenses, can't we at least give the right to a husband to demand sex from his wife after four nights?” he said.

Look at the similarity in the worldview of a person who would say what Ross is alleged to have said and someone who advocates legal marital rape. Both view sex as a commodity: something that women give and men take. Neither view women as owners of their sexuality. Rather, both seem to believe that a woman's husband owns her body for the purpose of satisfying his sexual pleasure. Neither discuss the ramifications of forced sexual intercourse on family dynamics or women's physical and emotional well-being. Neither address any non-illness-related reason a woman might legitimately withold consent from her husband, and indeed the decision over whether the reason is worthy isn't mentioned in Ross' statement and is entirely within the law's power (and not the woman's) in Mohseni.

American culture is called "rape culture" by feminists because of statements like the one Ross is alleged to have made. However, somehow we hold ourselves apart from Muslim governments, believing the US to be much more progressive and enlightened. However, our cultures are more similar than many in the West would like to admit, the difference is a matter of degree within the same basic model. Any society that works within the concept of "giving" women rights ignores the fact that women, as humans, are born with rights that nobody has the power to give or take away. If a society keeps women from acting on their own behalf and representing themselves in government and exercising bodily control and sexual agency, that society denies women's humanity.

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Marital Rape in Afghanistan

I wanted to address the Afghan law that many liberal and feminist bloggers have spoken about, which guarantees a man's right of sexual access to his wife. Under the law, a man has a right to have sex with his wife every fourth night (which I assume is a minimum). One of the law's drafters, Mohammad Asif Mohseni, has condemned the outcry from Western leaders (including Obama), saying that if the West wants a democracy in Afghanistan, then it needs to let the Afghan people pass laws like this, if the people decide they are necessary.

Mohseni's underlying argument boils down to "Western influence over our laws is unacceptable". This view seems to be shared by Noah Feldman, as described in his article Imposed Constitutionalism (37 Conn. L. Rev. 857, 869 (2005)). To thse who think Westerners should have little or no say in Afghanistan's laws, I must ask: are you serious? How can the West avoid interfering with Afghanistan's legal system? The US was attacked by the Taliban, which was effectively running Afghanistan, since its government was broken. As a response to a devastating attack, we invaded Afghanistan. The logical conclusion of that invasion, whenever it may come, must include a new, stable Afghan government, with American support. And, we as Americans have an obligation, having taken on the burden of invading and trying to stabilize the Afghan state, to safeguard human rights there.

Avoiding Western intrusion into Afghan affairs is impossible in 2009. In fact, an American refusal to get involved with this particular law would be a Western interference that comes down on the side of men who think women exist to be used for sex. There is no neutral, non-invasive ground for the US or the rest of the West in this situation. By standing idly by, Westerners are complicit in deprivation of Afghan women's constitutionally protected rights. We are complicit in the legalization of marital rape and the statutory reduction of women to sex objects rather than people. We ruin our own strategic objectives if we don't push back, because we contribute to the instability of the Afghan state when we support fundamentalists like Mohseni. When fundamentalists and regional clerics are given power over government and the laws thereof, they will not back off and support whatever government we pick to nominally run the country. Giving fundamentalist warlords an inch on these types of debates silences women and legitimizes virulent fundamentalism that reads no human rights guarantees in the Quran.

Mohseni contends that marital rape and women's sexual availability to their husbands is a Quranic principle, and is therefore beyond analysis and reproach:
Afghanistan is an Islamic state and its constitution defers to the Quran as the ultimate authority. Mr. Mohseni said the law simply reiterates rules from Islam's holy book.
The Quran, like every other authoritative religious text, is open to interpretation. Does the Bible say things that were only culturally appropriate in the context (temporal and cultural) in which it was written? You bet. Does the Torah? Sure. It is an indefensible position that the Quran, in 2009, necessarily restricts human rights and mandates that women function as objects of sexual gratification for their husbands regardless of their own feelings on the matter. There are 1.2 billion Muslims in the world (according to some sources). Not all of them practice or interpret their religion in the same way. It is unnecessary and inappropriate for the US to entertain arguments that the Quran mandates that women are their husband's property, or any argument that similarly reduces women's humanity. To accept such an argument is to support a hard line, fundamentalist interpretation rather than a more progressive, democratic interpretation. There is no reason to accept any interpretation of Islam that doesn't comport with modern understandings of human rights.

Our failure to insist upon a liberal interpretation of Islam in the laws of the Muslim governments we influence will doom our goals in Iraq ad Afghanistan by empowering fundamentalists there. Such a failure would also doom our efforts to achieve democracy in those countries, since it is disingenuous to describe a state as a democracy if it lacks meaningful participation by its women.




"

Monday, April 13, 2009

Family Law/Property Law

I'm adopting a new goal to post once per week, on Thursdays or Fridays. But so that I don't lose it, I wanted to talk about an idea I've been ruminating for a while: family law has its origins in property law. In order to flesh this out, I will need to figure out when property law as we understand it came into being and for whom. As for the Western world and the Anglo-American legal tradition, I know that all real property in England ultimately belonged to the crown. What about personal property? What regulations were there over a man regarding his livestock, and how were they different from regulations pertaining to women and children? Is the Bible helpful in understanding this question?

Same questions go for the Middle East. How did property law evolve there? When did a separate family law jurisprudence emerge, and was it part of church or secular adjudication? Is the Quran helpful in understanding this question as it pertains to the Middle East?

I work from a place of curiosity and deep offense with this question. The idea that I am less than a man because I am a woman has always been quite unpalatable to me. Knowing that women in different times or places literally had no human rights and were completely dependent on their fathers and husbands is hard to wrap my mind around. The very idea that my birth as female dooms me to different treatment for life is shocking and maddening. This is why my feminism gave rise to intersectional progressive values and secular humanism: I reject white, able-bodied men as the "default"of humanity. This world does not belong to one subset of its inhabitants.

How did this devaluation of women begin? Women's physical power to create life must have seemed divine in early humanity: goddess worship was most likely, quite common. I had a thought the other day that perhaps death in childbirth contributed to the devaluation of women. It seems inefficient today to keep half the world's population illiterate and weak. Maybe during most of human history, when women were married and pregnant in their teens and deaths in childbirth were frequent, educating women, or indeed becoming attached emotionally to them, must have seemed like a waste of time. Maybe our biology reduced us to death before the patriarchy reduced us to our biology.