Showing posts with label Afghanistan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Afghanistan. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 10, 2009

The Brothers Karzai: What are we really doing in Afghanistan?

Reports surfaced a couple weeks ago that the CIA is paying Ahmed Wali Karzai, Hamid Karzai's brother. So this means:

1) The CIA pays A. Karzai.
2) Karzai ALLEGEDLY uses this money in his ALLEGED role as a major player in Afghanistan's opium trade.
3) The opium trade supplies the Taliban.
4) The Taliban kills Americans.

The options are that the generals who want us to increase troops in Afghanistan didn't know that the CIA is pouring money into that country, or they did know. I don't know which would be worse.

Monday, August 17, 2009

Iran and Afghanistan: Contrasts in Securing Power

In Iran, Ahmadinejad is apparently set to nominate three women to the Iranian cabinet. The AP reports that these nominations appear "to be an attempt by Ahmadinejad to win the support of Iranian women as he fends off opposition claims that his re-election to the presidency in June was fraudulent." These would be the first female ministers Iran has had since the 1970's.

Iran, then, provides an example of a leader making concessions to vocal groups in order to safeguard his power. Women were a vocal and visible part of the uprising in Iran, and so Ahmadinejad is throwing them a bone by including women in his cabinet.

I contrast this with Afghanistan, where, as discussed in the previous post, Karzai is capitulating to fundamentalist voices by quietly passing a law that allows husbands to withhold food from wives who refuse to have sex with them, among other things. Rather than kill a law that would legalize marital rape, which caused international outcry in March, Karzai mollified outsiders and then passed the current law, which undermines women's rights to a similar degree.

The question I have is: why? Why does the regime in Afghanistan, which Americans put in place and have supported for 8 years, still need to placate warlords by stripping women of their rights? Why can Iran, one of the most repressive regimes in the world, tolerate more legal protection for women than Afghanistan? Why did the US even throw the Taliban regime out of Afghanistan if the US-supported regime would be similarly offensive to international standards of human rights?

Saturday, August 15, 2009

WTF is THIS?!?!?

Remember in April when there was international outcry about a law that legalized marital rape in Afghanistan? Remember how the president we support, Hamid Karzai, promised to fix it? Well, in Karzai's world I guess "fix it" means "implement it" because looky here. From the article:
The law gives a husband the right to withdraw basic maintenance from his wife, including food, if she refuses to obey his sexual demands. It grants guardianship of children exclusively to their fathers and grandfathers. It requires women to get permission from their husbands to work. It also effectively allows a rapist to avoid prosecution by paying "blood money" to a girl who was injured when he raped her.
With this law, Karzai is doing what other power hungry leaders in the region have done for years: sold out progressive principles, even when those are enshrined in the country's constitution, in order to cement their influence over local clerics and warlords. Afghanistan's constitution of 2004 promotes women's rights. You can read a nice breakdown of the constitution by Prof. Madhavi Sunder here.

Democracy cannot exist without the rule of law and the participation of a meaningful percentage of a country's population. The rule of law means that, to some extent, duress and fraud are not the primary means of making someone do something; that, to some extent, people abide by the laws the government sets out for them. People are more likely to do that when the laws are legitimate, according to the allocation of rights set up in that country's constitution. Constitutions are like compacts: the government lists the rights it has over the people and the people's representatives list the rights that the people reserve for themselves.

In Afghanistan, the rights of the people included rights for female people. When it made its constitution, Afghanistan elected to allow the International Human Rights Commission to enforce the Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW). CEDAW prohibits sex discrimination in both public and private realms. So, a law that allows a husband to withhold basic necessities like food from his wife if she won't have sex with him clearly enshrines sex discrimination into the laws of Afghanistan, which is unconstitutional. Patently unconstitutional laws like this undermine the rule of law profoundly.

Secondly, democracies in their modern form require a meaningful percentage of the population to participate. It's true that in Athens, a democracy could include only upper class men, but I'd like to think that we have a different view of human beings' worth than they did in ancient times. How can you have a functioning democracy when the government allows half the country's population to be abused? Women in Afghanistan can vote, but they can't leave the house without their husbands' permission according to this new law. That is an unsustainable faux-democracy, inspired by the desire to capitulate to fundamentalists and warlords. WTF is this?!?!?!

Friday, April 17, 2009

Afghanistan Update

Karzai is going to reverse the law legalizing marital rape and rolling back the rights of Afghan women.

Good job, internal and external outrage!

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Entitlement and Marital Rape

Sarah Palin's pick for Attorney General of Alaska is running into some problems. A letter by Leah Burton, reproduced here and here, says that Wayne Anthony Ross spoke at a 1991 meeting of the group Dads Against Discrimination. Burton's letter alleges that Ross said, "If a guy can't rape his wife, who's he gonna rape?" I have several things to say about this statement in isolation, not as an indicator of Ross' potential job performance as AG. It hasn't been proven that he said this yet.
  1. This statement might mean, "If a man can't rape his wife, he will inevitably go rape someone else, and that's not good." I would take issue with the idea that a man is inevitably a rapist. Even if this statement doesn't mean that all men are rapists, it might mean that those men who are rapists should confine their activities to one victim. I disagree that it's helpful to the world to assign one woman to absorb the pain of all potential victims. If a wife is made into the mechanism by which society controls rapists, then society completely ignores any punishment or accountability for rapists themselves. How about wives don't have to be victims of sexual assault at all, because men realize that women's bodies should be under individual women's control?
  2. The more conventional way to read this statement is "If a man can't rape his wife, then what is a wife for?" This view is akin to the idea that marital rape doesn't exist, because "rape" means "have sex with someone without their permission" and wives, through their marriage vows, give their husbands blanket sexual consent until the marriage ends or one spouse dies. This view depends on the idea that women are not people with full agency within marriage, and that their bodily integrity is secondary to their husbands' sexual desires.
The statement attributed to Ross led me to revisit Afghan leader Mohammad Asif Mohseni's statements about the law that grants a husband sexual access to his wife every fourth night. The Globe and Mail reported this story and Mr. Mohseni's statements:
“If she is not sick, and if she does not have another problem, it is the right of a man to ask for sex and she should make herself ready for it. This is the right of a man,” Mr. Mohseni explained.

Mr. Mohseni argued that women and men are very far from equal in today's Afghanistan and should not be treated as such. He pointed out that many rural women are illiterate and would not be able to find work if they were asked to provide some of the family's financial support. Men are typically the breadwinners in Afghan households, expected to provide for their wives and children.

“It is not possible for all women to pay the same amount of money as men are paying. For all these expenses, can't we at least give the right to a husband to demand sex from his wife after four nights?” he said.

Look at the similarity in the worldview of a person who would say what Ross is alleged to have said and someone who advocates legal marital rape. Both view sex as a commodity: something that women give and men take. Neither view women as owners of their sexuality. Rather, both seem to believe that a woman's husband owns her body for the purpose of satisfying his sexual pleasure. Neither discuss the ramifications of forced sexual intercourse on family dynamics or women's physical and emotional well-being. Neither address any non-illness-related reason a woman might legitimately withold consent from her husband, and indeed the decision over whether the reason is worthy isn't mentioned in Ross' statement and is entirely within the law's power (and not the woman's) in Mohseni.

American culture is called "rape culture" by feminists because of statements like the one Ross is alleged to have made. However, somehow we hold ourselves apart from Muslim governments, believing the US to be much more progressive and enlightened. However, our cultures are more similar than many in the West would like to admit, the difference is a matter of degree within the same basic model. Any society that works within the concept of "giving" women rights ignores the fact that women, as humans, are born with rights that nobody has the power to give or take away. If a society keeps women from acting on their own behalf and representing themselves in government and exercising bodily control and sexual agency, that society denies women's humanity.

Tuesday, April 14, 2009

Marital Rape in Afghanistan

I wanted to address the Afghan law that many liberal and feminist bloggers have spoken about, which guarantees a man's right of sexual access to his wife. Under the law, a man has a right to have sex with his wife every fourth night (which I assume is a minimum). One of the law's drafters, Mohammad Asif Mohseni, has condemned the outcry from Western leaders (including Obama), saying that if the West wants a democracy in Afghanistan, then it needs to let the Afghan people pass laws like this, if the people decide they are necessary.

Mohseni's underlying argument boils down to "Western influence over our laws is unacceptable". This view seems to be shared by Noah Feldman, as described in his article Imposed Constitutionalism (37 Conn. L. Rev. 857, 869 (2005)). To thse who think Westerners should have little or no say in Afghanistan's laws, I must ask: are you serious? How can the West avoid interfering with Afghanistan's legal system? The US was attacked by the Taliban, which was effectively running Afghanistan, since its government was broken. As a response to a devastating attack, we invaded Afghanistan. The logical conclusion of that invasion, whenever it may come, must include a new, stable Afghan government, with American support. And, we as Americans have an obligation, having taken on the burden of invading and trying to stabilize the Afghan state, to safeguard human rights there.

Avoiding Western intrusion into Afghan affairs is impossible in 2009. In fact, an American refusal to get involved with this particular law would be a Western interference that comes down on the side of men who think women exist to be used for sex. There is no neutral, non-invasive ground for the US or the rest of the West in this situation. By standing idly by, Westerners are complicit in deprivation of Afghan women's constitutionally protected rights. We are complicit in the legalization of marital rape and the statutory reduction of women to sex objects rather than people. We ruin our own strategic objectives if we don't push back, because we contribute to the instability of the Afghan state when we support fundamentalists like Mohseni. When fundamentalists and regional clerics are given power over government and the laws thereof, they will not back off and support whatever government we pick to nominally run the country. Giving fundamentalist warlords an inch on these types of debates silences women and legitimizes virulent fundamentalism that reads no human rights guarantees in the Quran.

Mohseni contends that marital rape and women's sexual availability to their husbands is a Quranic principle, and is therefore beyond analysis and reproach:
Afghanistan is an Islamic state and its constitution defers to the Quran as the ultimate authority. Mr. Mohseni said the law simply reiterates rules from Islam's holy book.
The Quran, like every other authoritative religious text, is open to interpretation. Does the Bible say things that were only culturally appropriate in the context (temporal and cultural) in which it was written? You bet. Does the Torah? Sure. It is an indefensible position that the Quran, in 2009, necessarily restricts human rights and mandates that women function as objects of sexual gratification for their husbands regardless of their own feelings on the matter. There are 1.2 billion Muslims in the world (according to some sources). Not all of them practice or interpret their religion in the same way. It is unnecessary and inappropriate for the US to entertain arguments that the Quran mandates that women are their husband's property, or any argument that similarly reduces women's humanity. To accept such an argument is to support a hard line, fundamentalist interpretation rather than a more progressive, democratic interpretation. There is no reason to accept any interpretation of Islam that doesn't comport with modern understandings of human rights.

Our failure to insist upon a liberal interpretation of Islam in the laws of the Muslim governments we influence will doom our goals in Iraq ad Afghanistan by empowering fundamentalists there. Such a failure would also doom our efforts to achieve democracy in those countries, since it is disingenuous to describe a state as a democracy if it lacks meaningful participation by its women.




"